Skip to main content
All Posts By

Curtis Clarke

Black and white photo of an older craftsman showing a young apprentice how to work at a workshop bench

From Taxonomy to Traction
Rebuilding the First Rung as Learning Infrastructure

By Blog, UpskillingNo Comments

We have never known more precisely which skills the AI economy will require, or less about how young people will come to possess them.

That gap has been on my mind for some time, and Ewan Simpson’s recent paper, When Is the Evidence Enough? Youth Labour Markets, AI, and the Cost of Waiting for Certainty, sharpened it. His opening line puts it plainly: “Something is going wrong at the point where young people enter the labour market.”

The World Economic Forum, the OECD, national skills councils and industry bodies have converged on a well-built skills architecture, and a parallel infrastructure of reskilling strategies and talent accelerators has grown up around it. Far less rigour has gone into a simpler question: where and how do people aged 18–25 acquire, apply and transfer those competencies?

That question is now urgent. Entry-level roles, long the place where textbook knowledge became working judgement, are under the most pressure in the occupations most exposed to AI; the Burning Glass Institute’s No Country for Young Grads documents how hard that first step has become. Yet the pathways that carry this load (work-integrated learning, apprenticeships, competency-based models and, above all, mentorship) are still treated as delivery detail rather than economic infrastructure.

Experts Who Never Emerge

The WEF’s own education work shows the problem in miniature. Shaping the Future of Learning (2026) lists sixteen conditions for education readiness, including employer and career partnerships and lifelong, student-driven learning. It is also unusually honest about the ground beneath them. Promising results from controlled studies rarely survive at system scale, and the first students to enter higher education after generative AI arrived are only now graduating, so the evidence is still thin.

Its sharpest warning is that AI may not replace experts so much as stop them from ever emerging.

That warning has an economic logic and warning. Expertise rests on tacit judgement, and tacit judgement is learned by doing the routine, codifiable work that once made up a first job: drafting, data entry, basic research, customer queries. As the LSE’s Grace Lordan points out, these are the tasks AI absorbs first. Each firm that automates them captures the saving, while the cost, a thinner pipeline of future experts, is borne by everyone.

Nor will the problem pass with the economic cycle. In Lordan’s words: “AI is not a recession. It does not pass.”

The blueprint, then, has been drawn on ground no one has surveyed. That calls less for planners than for builders: leaders prepared to construct new entry routes, test them under real conditions, and rebuild what fails.

The timing matters. The generation now entering the labour market is the first to find the bottom rung itself in question. A weak hiring cycle is only part of the reason; the larger part is that the work through which entry was once earned is being redesigned.

And the frameworks that will govern their pathways are being drafted largely without them in the room, even though, as the WEF’s Youth Pulse 2026 makes clear, young people have plenty to say about the world of work they are inheriting.

Waiting for Proof Is a Decision

To be fair, the evidence has not yet proven that AI is the main cause of young people’s struggles to find work. Slow growth, rising hiring costs, health pressures and post-pandemic caution all play a part.

But as Simpson argues, we have crossed the threshold for action, even if not for final attribution. Enough canaries in enough coal mines should change behaviour.

None of this requires waiting for a new skills framework. It requires organisations, educators and policymakers to treat the first rung as what it has always been: the economy’s learning infrastructure. Four moves would turn it from a casualty of AI into a launch pad.

1. Redesign the Rung, Don’t Remove It

When AI takes over routine tasks, the answer is to rebuild entry roles around what remains: supervised judgement, client contact, checking and improving AI output, and problems without a clean answer. Firms that cut junior roles outright are already finding the saving comes with a bill attached, as Fast Company reported this year. Cognizant and Pearson’s AI Workforce Pulse frames adaptability as the new imperative, and a well-designed first job is exactly where adaptability is built.

2. Treat Mentorship as Infrastructure

Mentorship is how tacit judgement passes from one generation to the next, and it is the pathway most at risk when junior roles disappear. It cannot run on goodwill and spare time. It needs to be designed, resourced and written into senior people’s objectives, in the same way we budget for systems and training.

3. Measure Conversion, Not Placements

Counting how many young people enter a programme tells us very little. The measure that matters is conversion: how many go on to do work that requires independent judgement, and how quickly they get there. Track that, and we will soon see which pathways work and which only look busy.

4. Build It With Young People, Not for Them

Many of those entering work are more fluent with AI tools than the managers designing their jobs. Research in Harvard Business Review argues that curious employees, wherever they sit in the hierarchy, can drive digital transformation when given the room. Bring young people into the design of entry routes as co-designers, not consultees.

The Question for Every Leader

If we get this wrong, we will have described the skills of the future economy in exquisite detail and quietly dismantled the mechanism by which a generation was meant to acquire them. If we get it right, the people we nearly locked out may be the ones who lead us through.

Are our organisations building the first rung, or pulling it up behind us?

References

Carnegie, M. (2026). Companies replaced entry-level workers with AI. Now they are paying the price. Fast Company.

Cognizant & Pearson (2026). The AI Workforce Pulse: The Adaptability Imperative.

Hill, L. A., Menon, S., Le Cam, A., Begag, L. & Grazina, K. (2026). Empower Your Most Curious Employees to Drive Your Digital Transformation. Harvard Business Review.

Levanon, G., Sigelman, M., et al. (2025). No Country for Young Grads. Burning Glass Institute.

Lordan, G. (2026a). AI means fewer graduate jobs: how to make sure they still exist in the future. LSE British Politics and Policy.

Lordan, G. (2026b). Is AI behind youth unemployment? LSE British Politics and Policy.

Simpson, E. (2026). When Is the Evidence Enough? Youth Labor Markets, AI, and the Cost of Waiting for Certainty. Narxoz Business School.

World Economic Forum (2026). Shaping the Future of Learning: Education Readiness for the Age of AI.

World Economic Forum (2026). Youth Pulse 2026: Insights from the Next Generation for a Changing World.

The Skills Imperative: Putting People First in a Technology-Driven World

By BlogNo Comments

We are living through a period of technological convergence unlike anything our skills and education systems were designed to navigate. Artificial intelligence, genomics, quantum computing, and advanced materials are not arriving sequentially — they are intersecting simultaneously, amplifying each other’s impact across every sector of the economy.

The World Economic Forum tells us that 39% of the core skills required for existing jobs will fundamentally shift by 2030, and that 59% of the global workforce will need reskilling or upskilling to meet that moment. And yet the dominant institutional response remains incremental: add an AI module here, a data analytics course there, and assume that credential accumulation will produce the convergence capabilities the economy demands. It will not. What convergence requires is something deeper — people who operate at the intersection of domain expertise and technological fluency, who bring analytical thinking, creativity, and judgment to environments where no algorithm can substitute for human insight.

When learning is embedded in meaningful work, relevant to a learner’s actual context, and designed through genuine partnership between educators, employers, and the learner themselves, the outcomes are transformative. The science of learning and the evidence from practice align on this: transformation requires engagement, not consumption.

This is why the learner must be placed at the centre of every skills strategy — not as a passive recipient of training designed around institutional convenience, but as the active protagonist of a development journey built around genuine capability outcomes. The most effective skills transformation models share a defining characteristic: they begin with a precise understanding of what people need to be able to do, they co-design learning around real work challenges, and they measure success not by completion rates but by demonstrated capability and economic impact.

When learning is embedded in meaningful work, relevant to a learner’s actual context, and designed through genuine partnership between educators, employers, and the learner themselves, the outcomes are transformative. The science of learning and the evidence from practice align on this: transformation requires engagement, not consumption.

The invitation — and the imperative — is for a different quality of leadership response. Industry, government, academia, and community institutions each hold a part of what is needed, but no single actor holds all of it. What this moment calls for is the willingness to co-design, co-invest, and co-own the outcomes of a skills system genuinely fit for a convergence economy.

The cost of inaction is not abstract: every unfilled role is lost productivity, every organisation that cannot find the talent to innovate is a missed opportunity, and every person we fail to prepare is human potential unrealised. We have the knowledge, the institutional capacity, and the will. What remains is the courage to move from incremental adjustment to genuine transformation — with the learner as our North Star.

 

Managing Canada’s AI Transformation: A Call for Collective Leadership

By BlogNo Comments

We have the research. We have the funding. Now we need coordinated action across all sectors.

 

Here’s a puzzle that should worry every Canadian leader: we are global champions at AI research but amateurs at AI workforce development.

Canada was first to launch a national AI strategy. Our researchers at the Vector Institute, Mila (Quebec Artificial Intelligence Institute), and Amii (Alberta Machine Intelligence Institute) set global standards. We rank alongside South Korea and Japan for AI governance. We have 132 world-class CIFAR (Canadian Institute for Advanced Research) AI Chairs producing breakthrough research.

Yet while AI adoption among Canadian businesses doubled in just one year, nearly half of workers are using AI tools without proper training. Youth unemployment hit 14.6%—the highest since 2010. About 4.2 million Canadian workers face significant job transformation from AI.

The gap between our research excellence and workforce readiness isn’t a policy failure—it’s a leadership opportunity that demands coordinated action across sectors. Each player brings essential capabilities: government’s strategic investment and policy coordination, industry’s real-world demand and co-investment capacity, and post-secondary institutions’ training expertise and regional reach.

Ireland’s Skillnet model shows us what coordinated action looks like: government providing strategic funding and policy frameworks, industry co-investing and defining skill needs, training institutions delivering targeted programs. The result? Over 70,000 workers upskilled annually through 70 industry-led networks.

Canada has a narrow window—perhaps 18 months—to create our own coordinated response before international competitors capture the economic benefits of AI transformation. But only if all three sectors embrace their roles as collective leaders in Canada’s AI transformation.

The Three-Sector Solution Canada Needs

Let’s be clear about what’s at stake. The Conference Board of Canada estimates AI could add $50 billion annually to our GDP if deployed correctly. Workers with AI skills command 25% wage premiums. Companies moving fast on AI achieve productivity growth five times higher than laggards.

But economic potential depends entirely on coordinated action between three essential players—and right now, they’re barely talking to each other.

Government has the policy levers and public investment capacity. Federal AI funding totals $2.4 billion, with substantial resources for infrastructure and workforce development. But government can’t deliver training at scale or identify specific skill gaps fast enough.

Industry has the demand signals and practical context. Companies know exactly which AI skills they need, and which traditional jobs are being transformed. But industry can’t build training infrastructure or serve workers beyond their own organizations.

Post-secondary institutions have the learning expertise and community reach. They can design effective programs and scale them across entire populations. But they can’t move fast enough without clear demand signals and sustained funding partnerships.

None of these sectors can solve Canada’s AI workforce challenge alone. But together, they could create something powerful: a coordinated system that matches Ireland’s Skillnet success but at the speed and scale AI transformation demands.

The question isn’t whether each sector has a role—it’s whether they’ll coordinate their efforts before the window closes.

Proven Models Show Coordinated Action Works

Skillnet Ireland demonstrates what happens when three sectors align their efforts. Government provides strategic funding and policy frameworks. Industry networks co-invest and define specific skill needs. Training institutions deliver targeted programs that match real workforce demands.

The results speak for themselves: over 70,000 workers upskilled annually through 70 industry-led networks, with 89% completion rates and 92% employment outcomes. Each euro of government investment leverages additional private sector funding.

Some Canadian examples are already moving in this direction, proving the concept works here too.

The Vector Institute combines government funding through CIFAR, industry sponsorship from companies like RBC and Shopify, and university expertise from across Ontario. Their coordinated approach has created 289 collaborative projects and 500 new jobs.

Scale AI has partnered with universities to retrain over 3,000 working professionals through industry-informed programs that lead directly to employment.

But these remain isolated successes rather than systematic transformation. We need to scale this coordination model across the country, with the urgency that AI transformation demands.

Every month we delay gives international competitors more time to capture the economic benefits of workforce transformation that should be ours.

Building Canada’s Coordinated Response

Creating a Canadian version of Ireland’s success requires each sector to step up in specific ways—and fast.

Government must lead with strategic coordination. This means moving beyond traditional funding silos to create integrated programs that reward three-way collaboration. Performance-based funding should incentivize industry partnership and workforce outcomes, not just academic metrics. Policy frameworks must enable rapid program development and cross-sector data sharing.

Industry must co-invest in workforce development as competitive strategy. This goes beyond hiring graduates to co-designing programs, providing real-world projects, and sharing expertise with institutions. Companies succeeding at AI understand that building workforce capability is as important as buying technology.

Post-secondary institutions must embrace speed and relevance as core values. This means developing new governance mechanisms for rapid program approval, measuring success by employment outcomes rather than just enrollment, and treating industry partnership as essential mission rather than optional activity.

The coordination challenge is real—these sectors speak different languages, operate on different timelines, and measure success differently. But AI transformation won’t wait for perfect alignment.

Countries like Singapore and Estonia are proving that coordinated action at speed is possible. Their systematic approach to workforce transformation is already attracting international investment and talent that could have come to Canada.

The Competition Is Moving Faster Than We Are

The window for Canadian leadership is closing rapidly. While we debate coordination, other countries are implementing systematic workforce transformation.

Singapore’s $27 billion AI investment includes mandatory collaboration between government, industry, and all research institutions. Their AI Apprenticeship Programme achieves 90%+ graduate placement rates because all three sectors share responsibility for outcomes.

Estonia launched nationwide AI tool access for every student and teacher in months, not years, through coordinated government-industry partnerships.

South Korea’s $69.3 million textbook transformation program required unprecedented coordination between education ministry, technology companies, and universities—completed in under 18 months.

These countries aren’t necessarily smarter than Canada—they’re just acting with greater urgency and better coordination. They understand that AI transformation success depends on systematic collaboration, not isolated excellence.

Canada pioneered a national AI strategy in 2017, giving us a four-year head start. But first-mover advantage disappears quickly if you don’t follow through with coordinated implementation.

We have perhaps 12-18 months before the global competition for AI talent and investment makes Canada’s current advantages irrelevant. The question isn’t whether we can afford to coordinate—it’s whether we can afford not to.

The Time for Coordinated Action Is Now

Canada has everything needed to lead the global transition to an AI economy: world-class research, substantial government investment, innovative companies, and educational institutions with global reputations. What we need now is the coordination to use these assets strategically.

The choice facing us isn’t between change and stability—change is happening whether we coordinate it or not. The choice is between leading global AI transformation through systematic collaboration or watching others capture the economic benefits of research breakthroughs that happened in our labs.

Government leaders: Create funding mechanisms that reward three-way collaboration, not institutional silos. Develop performance metrics that track workforce outcomes across sectors. Move at the speed of technology change, not traditional policy cycles.

Industry leaders: Co-invest in workforce development as competitive strategy, not corporate charity. Share real-time skill requirements with institutions. Commit to multi-year partnerships that allow program development at scale.

Post-secondary leaders: Embrace rapid program development and industry partnership as core mission. Measure success by graduate employment outcomes and regional economic impact. Treat coordination with other sectors as strategic imperative.

All of us: Advocate for the coordinated approach Canada needs. Support leaders who prioritize collaboration over competition. Hold all sectors accountable for the workforce transformation our economy demands.

Ireland’s Skillnet model proves that government, industry, and training institutions can work together to transform workforce capability. Canada needs our own version of this coordination—built for AI transformation and delivered with the urgency this moment demands.

The research advantages that made Canada an AI leader won’t protect us if we can’t translate them into workforce capability. But if we coordinate our efforts now, we can turn our AI research excellence into lasting economic advantage.

Canada’s moment is now. Our three sectors hold the keys together. Let’s use them.

Beyond the Status Quo: A Call for Transformative Educational Partnerships

By BlogNo Comments

Propero Learning Systems’ recent Accelerate2024 conference brought into sharp focus a critical challenge facing our national skills ecosystem: the growing disconnect between post-secondary institutions and industry sectors. A recent survey of 102 national industry associations found a staggering 68% have not collaborated with post-secondary institutions to co-develop curriculum or create meaningful skills pathways. Among those who tried, few reported successful outcomes. The barriers are familiar to many of us: bureaucratic timelines that render technical knowledge obsolete before courses launch, curriculum control mechanisms that limit industry input, and economic models that make collaboration prohibitively expensive. These are not just academic problems—they are strategic challenges that directly impact our ability to develop the talent pipeline our organizations desperately need.

But this is not a moment for frustration; it is an opportunity for strategic redesign. Our most innovative companies have always solved complex problems by creating new frameworks, and now we must apply that same creative thinking to skills development. We need to move beyond traditional engagement models and develop dynamic, real-time collaboration mechanisms that allow for rapid curriculum adaptation, meaningful industry input, and economically viable continuing education programs.

The economic development implications are profound. By creating more responsive skills ecosystems, we can dramatically reduce talent gaps, accelerate workforce readiness, and enhance our national and regional productivity. This requires a willingness to challenge existing structures, invest in new collaborative models, and view educational institutions not as distant entities, but as critical strategic partners in our economic future.

This is not an occasion for resignation, but for innovation. Our academic institutions have always been at the forefront of societal transformation, and now we are called to reimagine our approach to skills development. The traditional model of curriculum development—insulated and slow-moving—is no longer tenable in an economy characterized by rapid technological shifts and evolving workforce needs. We must become more agile, more responsive, and more collaborative.

The challenge before us is to deconstruct the existing paradigms. We need to create flexible, dynamic pathways for industry input, accelerate our curriculum development processes, and develop more economically accessible continuing education models. This requires breaking down internal silos, re-examining our governance structures, and cultivating a mindset of continuous adaptation. Our institutions have the creative genius to lead this transformation—we simply need the collective will to do so.

The time for admiration of these challenges has passed. Now is the moment of action. We invite academic and industry leaders across sectors to join us in pioneering a new approach to skills ecosystem development—one where industry and education are true, responsive partners in preparing our workforce for the future. Together, we can transform our approach, close the skills gap, and position our organizations and our nation for sustained economic success.